Top Surgery vs. Mastectomy: What is the Difference?

Understanding the difference between top surgery and mastectomy is important for your gender-affirming care. Top surgery is a way for you to reshape your chest, aligning your physical appearance with your gender identity by removing breast tissue. On the other hand, mastectomy is a procedure typically performed for health reasons, such as treating breast cancer. While both surgeries involve changes to the chest, they serve different purposes.

Top surgery can be a vital step in your gender-affirming care journey. Healthcare providers must acknowledge the distinction between top surgery and mastectomy to ensure you receive the right medical care. Understanding why chest surgery matters in gender-affirming care empowers you to make informed decisions that support both your physical and mental health as you work towards self-affirmation.

If you're considering procedures to masculinize your chest, it's important to know what to expect with top surgery.

Transgender Top Surgery

Transgender top surgery is a pivotal aspect of your gender-affirming care. It involves removing breast tissue to reshape your chest, achieving a more masculine or gender-neutral look. There are different types of top surgery. Options include double incision, periareolar, and keyhole techniques. Double incision is the most common. It involves horizontal incisions with nipple grafts. It is best for larger chest sizes. Periareolar, or keyhole surgery, is used for those with smaller chests. It involves minimal incisions around the areola. The keyhole technique keeps nipple sensation and reduces scarring.

By understanding each technique, you can choose the option that best suits your goals. The outcomes are transformative both physically and emotionally.


Mastectomy for Medical Reasons

A mastectomy, on the other hand, is a surgery used to treat conditions such as breast cancer. The extent of the disease might require the removal of the entire breast tissue. This surgery is performed in the presence of a large tumor, multiple tumors in the breast, when cancer has spread and, in some cases, as a preventative measure. Surgical approaches vary. A simple mastectomy involves removing the entire breast tissue but leaves the chest muscles intact. Radical mastectomies remove the chest muscles. Post-care following mastectomy involves a recovery period. It may include reconstructive surgery to restore the appearance of the breasts. Therapies like chemotherapy or radiation may be recommended based on the medical diagnosis. A mastectomy is important to improve long-term outcomes for those facing a cancer diagnosis.

Surgical Goals and Objectives

Whether it's for gender affirmation or medical needs, the goals for top surgery and mastectomy are based on the purpose of each procedure. Top surgery is often linked with gender-affirming care. The primary goal is to align the chest appearance with the individual’s gender identity. It involves removing the breast tissue and reshaping the chest. This creates a masculine or gender-neutral appearance. The procedure considers factors such as chest size, nipple placement, and overall aesthetics.

Mastectomy for medical reasons including breast cancer, has a different set of goals. The primary goal is to eliminate cancerous cells by removing the affected breast tissue. The surgery often ensures the complete removal of the tumor. The operation also allows the doctor to check lymph nodes for cancer spread and preserve chest muscles. The focus is on cancer treatment and prevention. The surgery team works to give patients the best results by focusing on the medical reasons for the procedure and lessening any physical or emotional effects. 

Whether for gender affirmation or medical needs, the goal of a top surgery is to meet the specific needs and wishes of each individual.

Breast Reconstruction and Preservation

Breast reconstruction and preservation are top concerns in both top surgery and mastectomy. Both surgeries cater to your individual preferences and needs. In top surgery, the goal is to contour the chest, matching your appearance to your gender identity. Some may choose breast preservation. This allows for an androgynous appearance. Others opt for reconstruction. This might include various techniques such as implants or tissue grafts.

In a mastectomy, reconstruction aims to restore the breast appearance after removal. This can involve immediate reconstruction during the mastectomy or a delayed procedure. The choice between preservation and reconstruction depends on your preferences. It can also depend on health factors and the desired visual outcome. The goal is to provide options for diverse needs. Each operation should contribute to overall well-being and health.


Psychological and Emotional Factors

Emotions play a significant role in both a top surgery and  mastectomy. If you have top surgery as part of gender-affirming care, the impact is often transformative. It offers you relief from gender dysphoria and helps foster a positive sense of identity.

In the case of mastectomy, you may experience a different range of emotions. These can include fear, grief, and body image concerns. The impact goes beyond overcoming the emotional challenges that are tied with a breast cancer diagnosis. The removal of breast tissue can be life-saving, but it can affect self-esteem and femininity.

Support and counseling are recommended for your recovery from both procedures. These tools help you navigate emotions and foster resilience.

Transgender Top Surgery Experiences

Every transition journey is unique and deserves celebration. Meet Nova, a non-binary individual who chose to have top surgery as part of their transition. At 27, they bravely embraced their true identity and came out as trans. They had never felt a connection to their chest and experienced discomfort with it. Upon finally sharing their authentic self with the world, the pieces fell into place, and they made the decision to undergo a transformative journey to remove their breasts.

Nova chose Dr. Angela Rodriquez, founder of ART Surgical in San Francisco, to perform top surgery. After a consultation, Dr. Rodriguez decided that a double incision technique with nipple areola reconstruction would be best. Nova immediately connected with Dr. Rodriguez, sharing that her blend of humor, sweetness and expertise makes her a remarkable and caring doctor. The end result left Nova feeling more confident in themselves. 

Stories like Nova's inspire us and show us that self-discovery can lead to positive change. Learn more about their story and experience with ART Surgical below:

Comfortable in Their Own Skin: Why One Patient Chose Dr. Angela Rodriguez

Celebrating Breast Cancer Survivors

Undergoing a mastectomy requires a tremendous amount of courage. Celebrating breast cancer survivors involves acknowledging the strength and bravery displayed in facing the challenges of a breast cancer diagnosis, along with the necessary surgeries and treatments. The triumph goes beyond physical healing and includes mental and emotional strength. Recovery is not solely about healing the body. It entails finding a sense of normalcy and well-being after diagnosis.

The transformative journey of breast cancer survivors often includes rebuilding self-esteem and fostering a positive body image. These inspiring stories bring hope and serve as a reminder of the importance of support networks and resilience. Celebrating individuals recognizes the strength of spirit and provides support for the journey toward health and recovery.    

How to Choose the Right Procedure

Choosing the right procedure requires careful understanding of your needs and goals. Deciding on the right surgery is important and depends on different factors, including your health and desired physical appearance. Whether it is top surgery for gender alignment or mastectomy for a health reason, you should talk openly with your doctors. They can help you understand what each surgery involves and how it might affect your body and feelings. Your personal preferences and how you want to look after the surgery are important too. The main thing is to make sure the surgery you choose feels right for you and helps you feel good about yourself.

The Role of Medical and Mental Healthcare Professionals

To explore a top surgery further, set up a meeting with a gender-affirming doctor. Choose an experienced doctor who can guide you through all the options and create a personalized care plan that suits you best.

Dr. Angela Rodriguez, a renowned transgender and non-binary surgeon in San Francisco, established ART Surgical with the goal of delivering personalized and empathetic gender-affirming healthcare. Recognizing the need for specialized surgical services for transgender, non-binary, and gender-diverse individuals, she strives to provide care that aligns with the unique goals of each person.

Click the link below to arrange your consultation and talk about your options with Dr. Rodriguez, a dedicated plastic surgeon in Northern California providing gender-affirming care to individuals across the U.S.

Please make sure to answer all the questions before submission
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.